13 min read time
Table of Contents
What Happens When the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Can't Cover Your Injuries?
If the at-fault driver's insurance doesn't fully cover your injuries and damages after a car accident, your underinsured/uninsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage can help cover the gap. UM/UIM pays your documented losses, medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, up to the UM/UIM limit on your policy.
If you don't have UM/UIM, your health or MedPay coverage can help cover medical expenses, but it doesn't compensate for lost wages, pain and suffering, and property damage.
If you don't have health insurance or MedPay, you may have to explore other options such as identifying liable third parties or going after the driver's personal assets, which can be substantially more complex than going after a driver's insurance policy limits, so it's crucial to work with a car accident lawyer in Las Vegas if it happens to reach this.
Why Policy Limits Often Fall Short of Serious Injury Costs
The problem isn't often the damage in a car accident. It's the lack of money available to pay for it. Insurance policy limits determine the maximum compensation a victim can receive through an at-fault driver's insurance policy.
For example, in Nevada under NRS 485.185, the minimum liability insurance coverage limit is $25,000. This means an accident involving a driver carrying only the legally required insurance coverage could cap your personal injury claim at $25,000. This limit rarely covers the cost of serious injury treatment, long-term care, or lost earning capacity.
As a result, serious car accident victims are left with significant gaps in their compensation.
Who Pays When Damages Exceed the Available Coverage
When the at-fault driver's insurance coverage falls short of covering all of your damages, you may have the following options to cover your damages fully:
- File an underinsured motorist claim with your insurance company to pay for the gap. Only available if your auto policy contains it.
- Hold the at-fault driver personally responsible under NRS 41.130. This means that they may have to pay out of pocket or have their wages garnished for any damages that exceed their insurance limits.
- If you choose to hold the at-fault driver personally responsible and they have additional assets, such as savings, investments, or real estate, you may be able to use them to satisfy your claim.
- You may be able to recover compensation from other sources, such as health insurance, disability insurance, or workers' compensation.
Out of all available options, filing an underinsured motorist claim or using another type of insurance coverage is typically the easiest and quickest way to cover remaining damages.
What Should You Do If the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Isn't Enough?
When the at-fault driver's insurance can't cover your injuries, follow these steps to protect your rights and maximize recovery:
- Confirm the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Policy Limits
- Document Your Injuries and Financial Losses
- Avoid Accepting a Settlement Before Reviewing Your Options
In cases involving an uninsured driver, it's highly recommended to involve a Las Vegas car accident attorney to ensure your case is pursued correctly and you're taking the most advantageous path for your situation.
Confirm the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Policy Limits
Before concluding that the at-fault driver's policy won't cover your damages, confirm their policy limits by contacting the at-fault driver's insurance company and asking about the available coverage. Also ask whether the at-fault driver has any optional auto insurance add-ons, such as umbrella insurance or higher liability limits.
Once you confirm the at-fault driver's insurance limits, compare them to your past, current, and future damages to determine if the available policy can sufficiently cover your losses.
Document Your Injuries and Financial Losses
If the at-fault driver's insurance doesn't fully cover your damages, build a paper trail that shows the real cost of your injuries so you'll know how large the gap is. Here's how to document injuries and financial losses for the most effective legal claim.
Starting with medical care and records:
- Seek Medical Treatment Right Away: Obtain care even if you feel fine. Insurers often use delayed treatment to argue that your injuries aren't serious.
- Keep Every Medical Record: Visit notes, diagnostic imaging, prescriptions, physical therapy reports, and billing statements. Use a calendar to track each treatment, date, provider, and diagnosis.
- Maintain a Daily Injury Journal: Write pain levels, symptoms, sleep quality, missed workdays, and activities you can't do because of your injuries. You'll need this for both liability and underinsured motorist claims.
Next, with financial documents related to the car accident:
- Collect Medical Bills and Explanation of Benefits (EOBs): Organize them chronologically and note what's been paid, what's outstanding, and what was covered by another insurance.
- Track Lost Wages: Start with 12 months of pay stubs and W-2s. Ask your employer for a letter confirming your income, the dates you missed work, and any reduced hours or sick leave used.
- Document Out-of-Pocket Costs: Pharmacy receipts, copays, parking fees, medical transportation, rental car, home modifications, and help with chores or childcare.
- Self-Employed Financial Logging: If you're self-employed, keep invoices, tax returns, and records of any work you had to decline due to injuries.
Now, check your own insurance coverage and limits to determine how much of the gap you may be able to cover using your own insurer:
- Gather Your Own Policy Documents: Note your liability coverage limits and underinsured motorist coverage limits. These are key for determining whether your coverage falls short.
- File a Claim: If you have uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, submit a UM/UIM claim promptly.
With all the evidence gathered, you must keep it organized to use it more effectively in negotiations and in court:
- Use a Master File: Physical binder or secure digital folder. Create separate sections for scene evidence, medical records, financial documents, and a personal impact journal.
- Take Photos of Visible Injuries: Capture the progress of your injuries over time.
- Save All Communication with Insurers: Emails, letters, call logs, and rejection notices.
- Get Police Reports and Witness Statements: These add third-party credibility to your account.
- Work with Your Attorney to Organize Your Documentation: They can help you file claims with your own insurance, apply for UM/UIM benefits, and track your case progress.
Avoid Accepting a Settlement Before Reviewing Your Options
If the at-fault driver's insurance is insufficient to cover your injuries, you should avoid accepting a policy-limits settlement without considering other potential sources of compensation. For example, in Nevada, where the minimum bodily injury liability coverage is $25,000, the insurer might offer this full amount, which may seem generous at first.
However, your damages could be much greater, and accepting a settlement often requires signing a release of liability, which may prevent you from pursuing additional compensation from the parties you release.
Before you accept a settlement from the other party's insurer or your own insurer, it's crucial to have one of our Las Vegas car accident attorneys review your damages, including lost wages, medical expenses, and future treatment costs, before accepting a settlement.
Can You Collect More Than the At-Fault Driver's Policy Limit?
Yes. Even if the at-fault driver's liability insurance is inadequate, you still have options to recover compensation. If you have underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, you may be able to receive additional benefits through your own insurance company, provided they fall within your coverage limits and the value of your claim.
You may also be able to collect from your health insurance (if available), and your employer's workers' comp benefits, depending on your coverage and the type of accident.
Why Insurers Generally Stop Paying at the Policy Limit
This is the situation most people face after a serious crash. Even though your damages exceed the other driver's policy limits, the liability insurer will generally stop paying once it hits the policy limit because the contract caps its obligation.
So if the at-fault driver's liability policy pays the maximum allowed, your injuries and expenses may still be uncovered. That's why underinsured motorist coverage matters because it offers additional compensation for qualifying injury-related losses that exceed the at-fault driver's available liability coverage, subject to your specific UIM limits and the terms outlined in your policy.
When Bad Faith Failure to Settle May Increase Insurer Liability
Insurance companies can face increased liability beyond policy limits if they act in bad faith. This can occur when an insurer unreasonably refuses to settle a claim within the available policy limit, potentially exposing its policyholder to an excess judgment.
A real-life Nevada example is Allstate Insurance Co. v. Miller, 125 Nev. 300 (2009), where the Nevada Supreme Court held that insurers must give equal thought to their policyholders' interests and properly inform them of settlement opportunities. Failing to do so could open the insurer up to a bad-faith claim.
Additionally, under NRS 686A.310, unfair claim settlement practices, such as failing to make a fair settlement when liability is clearly established, are prohibited. Violating this statute could constitute grounds for a separate claim under Nevada law.
However, an insurance company's refusal to pay on a claim doesn't automatically establish bad faith. Instead, it depends on whether or not the insurance company breached its legal obligations.
How Underinsured Motorist Coverage Works
Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage can provide additional compensation when the at-fault driver's bodily injury liability insurance is insufficient to cover your injuries. Depending on your policy and the accident's specific circumstances, UIM coverage may help cover additional medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other qualifying injury-related damages.
For instance, if you suffer $80,000 in injury damages and the at-fault driver's available bodily injury liability coverage totals only $50,000, you might be able to claim the additional $30,000 through your Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist coverage, provided your policy limits and Nevada law permit it.
However, UIM benefits are not automatically paid out. Your insurance company may investigate liability, assess your injuries, and dispute the amount of compensation you are owed.
Underinsured vs. Uninsured Motorist Coverage
Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage is triggered when the at-fault driver has no insurance. Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage kicks in when the other driver has insurance, but their limits fall short of your losses. In Nevada, these two coverages are bundled together in an optional UM/UIM auto policy.
Both UM and UIM cover the same damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other compensable damages. Under NRS 687B.145(2), insurance companies in Nevada must offer UM/UIM coverage at the same bodily injury limits you selected for liability, but you are not required to purchase it.
How to Check Whether Your Policy Includes UM/UIM Coverage
To confirm whether your policy includes uninsured and underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage, review your declarations page and policy documents:
- Check Insurance Policy: Look for UM/UIM coverage lines on your declarations page. They're typically labeled "Uninsured Motorist Bodily Injury" or "UM/UIM Bodily Injury."
- Review Coverage Limits: Check the coverage limits to ensure they match or exceed your bodily injury liability limits. UM/UIM limits should match your liability limits unless you've elected lower limits.
- Check If You Rejected UM/UIM: Verify whether you rejected the coverage in writing when you signed your policy. If you rejected UM/UIM coverage, a signed rejection form should be attached to your policy documents.
- Speak with Your Insurer: Contact your insurance company if you're unsure whether your policy includes UM/UIM coverage or if you need help reviewing your policy documents.
Stacking Multiple Policies for Additional Protection
Nevada drivers who insure multiple vehicles or have multiple applicable auto insurance policies may be eligible to combine their uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage limits through a process known as policy stacking.
For example, if you own two vehicles each with $25,000 in Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) coverage, stacking these policies could potentially provide up to $50,000 in combined coverage for a qualifying claim.
However, NRS 687B.145(1) allows insurers to prohibit the stacking of policies under certain conditions. Anti-stacking provisions must be clearly written and prominently displayed. Additionally, stacking restrictions might be unenforceable if policyholders obtain separate coverage for the same risk and pay premiums calculated for full reimbursement under that coverage.
The Nevada Supreme Court addressed the enforceability of anti-stacking provisions in Neumann v. Standard Fire Insurance Co., 101 Nev. 206 (1985).
How Common Are Uninsured and Underinsured Drivers?
According to an Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist report between 2017 and 2023 by the Insurance Research Council, one in three drivers, or 33.4% in the U.S., were either uninsured or underinsured in 2023, a 10% increase compared to 2017. This increase could be partially attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic.
With 6,180,241 car accidents nationally in 2024, the risk of being involved in a motor vehicle accident with an underinsured or uninsured driver is real.
What If the At-Fault Driver Has No Insurance at All?
When a driver with no insurance injures you, your options for recovering compensation often become narrower and more difficult. In these cases, you can still file a claim with your own insurance company under your uninsured motorist coverage, if you have it.
You can also file a lawsuit against the driver, but collecting on a judgment can be difficult since many uninsured drivers don't have the assets to satisfy a court judgment.
What Other Sources of Compensation May Be Available?
Several additional sources of compensation may be available in a car accident case. These include:
- Medical Payments Coverage
- Employer Policies and Commercial Vehicle Coverage
- Third-Party Liability Claims Against Other Responsible Parties
- Product Liability Claims for Defective Parts
Medical Payments Coverage
Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay) is an optional coverage option in Nevada that can cover immediate medical expenses after a car accident. You can use MedPay regardless of fault and while your car accident claim is unresolved.
Under NRS 687B.145(3), insurers in Nevada must offer MedPay with a minimum of $1,000, but you can increase your coverage limit, typically to between $1,000 and $10,000.
Since MedPay limits tend to be low, it's good for covering small medical expense gaps after an accident with an underinsured driver, but it often fails to cover gaps created by large treatment costs fully.
Employer Policies and Commercial Vehicle Coverage
If the motor vehicle accident involved a driver who was performing work duties such as delivering goods, transporting passengers via a rideshare app, or operating a fleet vehicle for work purposes, you may be able to seek compensation from their employer's insurance policy under the doctrine of vicarious liability.
This doctrine makes employers responsible for employees' actions while they're performing work-related tasks, so even if the driver is underinsured, you'll most likely be targeting their employer's larger commercial policy. However, exceptions apply, so review your case with our car accident attorneys to understand the specifics.
Additionally, if the situation is reversed and you're an employee who gets injured in a car accident while performing work duties, you may be able to file a workers' compensation claim with your company in addition to a claim against the other driver's insurer.
Third-Party Liability Claims Against Other Responsible Parties
When the at-fault driver's insurance coverage falls short, you may have additional options. Third-party liability claims are a common way to seek additional financial recovery.
In addition to the driver, other parties might be at fault for your injuries. This could include manufacturers, employers, pedestrians, or other drivers.
Third-party claims may also be possible if dangerous road conditions or other environmental factors caused the accident. In those cases, the property owner or the relevant authority might be liable for injuries caused by unsafe conditions.
Product Liability Claims for Defective Parts
If a defective vehicle part contributes to the accident, the manufacturer, distributor, or seller may be held partially liable for any injuries or damages through a product liability claim. Examples of defective vehicle parts that could contribute to or worsen an accident include defective brakes, tires, airbags, and steering systems.
A successful product liability claim could increase your coverage options beyond the responsible driver.
What Happens When Multiple Victims Share the Same Policy?
If multiple people are injured in the same accident, they all may need to share the same at-fault driver liability coverage when seeking compensation for their damages. Under Nevada law, NRS 485.185 requires auto insurance to carry bodily injury liability limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident.
Under this requirement, a driver could injure three people in a car accident and have only $50,000 in available coverage across all three claims. In serious accidents involving a minimum-insured at-fault driver, victims often recover less than their total losses and must seek other means of compensation.
Can You Sue the At-Fault Driver Personally?
You can sue the at-fault driver personally rather than their insurance company, as the driver is legally responsible for any harm they cause. However, under their insurance policy, the insurance company will often step in to defend the driver and pay for your injuries up to the policy limits.
However, there are important considerations to personally suing a driver, including:
- The driver's personal assets may be limited. Even if you win the lawsuit, you may not be able to collect the full judgment if the driver doesn't have enough money or property to pay.
- Nevada allows you to collect judgments through wage garnishment under NRS 31.295, or liens under NRS 17.150, which can help ensure you get paid. However, this can be a lengthy and complicated process.
- An at-fault driver may be able to file for bankruptcy and discharge a personal injury judgment stemming from ordinary negligence, such as poor judgment or distraction. However, judgments arising from injuries caused by driving while intoxicated are typically non-dischargeable under bankruptcy code 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(9).
In conclusion, you can sue the at-fault driver personally if the insurance company cannot pay your claim, but several factors are worth considering. Working with an experienced car accident attorney from our law firm who also understands personal judgment can help you navigate these options and ensure you get the compensation you deserve.
Weighing the Cost of a Lawsuit Against the Driver's Assets
You might not have to sue the at-fault driver personally, but if you do, it's important to consider whether the lawsuit is financially worthwhile. Personal lawsuits against at-fault drivers can be costly and may not always result in financial recovery. In these cases, you should focus on whether the driver has enough money to pay for your injuries and medical bills.
This is often referred to as whether the driver is "judgment-proof." If you cannot collect the money you're owed, then suing the at-fault driver personally may not be the best path forward.
Contact Us Today
The Rodney Okano Law Offices is a Las Vegas Law Firm that specializes in representing those injured in motor vehicle accidents and those looking to become debt-free through Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Our firm has been in Nevada for over 20 years and has helped thousands with their car accident claims and bankruptcy filings. We offer a free attorney consultation, which can be set up by calling or sending an email inquiry.